HOME > WORLD > China and the Belt and Road: Isolation or Ambition?
China and the Belt and Road
by

China and the Belt and Road: Isolation or Ambition?

While China possesses vast landmass, its ambitious One Belt One Road initiative (also known as the Belt and Road Initiative or BRI) represents China’s strategy to overcome isolation. This massive infrastructure project spanning Southeast Asia and beyond raises important questions: Is this truly about mutual development and connectivity, or does it represent a more strategic attempt to expand Chinese influence across South East Asian countries and further abroad?

What Is China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)?

Launched in 2013, China’s Belt and Road Initiative (also called One Belt One Road or OBOR) is an ambitious mega-project aiming to connect Asia, Africa, and Europe through highways, railways, ports, and pipelines, with China at the center. The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) spans across Southeast Asia and extends beyond, creating new corridors for trade and development. While Beijing officially emphasizes economic cooperation, many analysts and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) view it as a modern form of “debt diplomacy.”

The One Belt One Road initiative operates through a systematic approach:

  1. China provides massive loans to developing countries, especially in South East Asia
  2. Chinese state-owned companies implement infrastructure projects using these funds
  3. When countries fail to repay loans, they risk surrendering strategic assets to China

The Debt Trap: Real-World Examples in Southeast Asia and Beyond

Several countries, particularly in South East Asia, have already experienced economic crises due to Belt and Road related debt, prompting the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to issue warnings[1]:

  • Mongolia: Owing approximately $600 million to China through Belt and Road projects, Chinese companies have secured rights to extract rare earth elements and fossil fuels.[2]
  • Laos: A prominent South East Asian country unable to meet One Belt One Road repayment terms, Laos surrendered 70% of its national railway to Chinese companies.[3]
  • Tajikistan: Reports indicate the country ceded gold mines after failing to repay Chinese loans under the Belt Road Initiative.[4]
  • Pakistan: The China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), a flagship project of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), has plunged Pakistan into massive debt, forcing it to seek IMF assistance.[5]
  • Sri Lanka: After defaulting on a $1.3 billion loan tied to the One Belt One Road initiative, Sri Lanka leased the Hambantota Port to China for 99 years.[6]

Other South East Asian countries including Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Myanmar have also modified their laws and policies under pressure from Chinese investments through the Belt and Road Initiative.[7]

Growing Backlash Against Chinese Influence in Southeast Asia

Beyond financial burdens warned about by the International Monetary Fund (IMF)[8], China’s interference through the Belt and Road Initiative has triggered anti-Chinese protests, political instability, and widespread distrust across South East Asian countries:

  • Vietnam: With a long history of conflict with China, this South East Asian nation maintains low exposure to One Belt One Road debt but harbors strong resistance to Chinese influence.[9]
  • Malaysia: Former Prime Minister Mahathir canceled $22 billion worth of Belt and Road projects in 2018, citing unfair terms that threatened Malaysian sovereignty.[10]
  • Philippines, India, and Taiwan: These nations are strengthening cooperation with the United States to counter Chinese influence spreading through the One Belt One Road Initiative.[11]

China’s Geographic Dilemma and the Purpose of Belt and Road

China shares borders with 14 countries—more than any other nation—creating complex geopolitical challenges that the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) aims to address[12]:

  • In 1979, China and Vietnam fought a war that divided the region, creating lasting tensions in Southeast Asia.[13]
  • Border disputes with India in the Himalayas continue to simmer, affecting regional stability.[14]
  • While Russia is currently an ally, historical relations between the two countries have been delicate, influencing China’s Belt and Road strategy.[15]

With suspicious neighbors in South East Asia and growing international distrust, the Belt and Road Initiative serves a dual purpose: economic expansion and geopolitical influence to overcome what some analysts describe as China’s “strategic isolation.”[16]

Can China’s Belt and Road Initiative Surpass Western Influence?

Not yet, according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF)[17]. Although China’s economy continues to grow, its aggressive Belt and Road tactics are facing significant pushback. Many South East Asian countries are reconsidering their participation in the One Belt One Road Initiative and exploring cooperation with the United States instead[18]. The IMF has repeatedly warned that Belt and Road participant countries face significant debt risks[19]. Without allies, China’s expansion strategy through Belt and Road (also known as 1 Belt 1 Road) inevitably faces limitations despite its ambitious scope.

Conclusion: The Future of the Belt and Road Initiative

China’s Belt and Road Initiative (One Belt One Road) began as a vision for global connectivity but has transformed into a controversial tool for expanding Chinese influence, particularly across South East Asian countries[20]. The world is watching this ambitious project, and many nations are pushing back against what the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has identified as potential debt traps[21]. Whether China can address these concerns and reposition its Belt and Road strategy remains to be seen, but the tension between isolation and ambition continues to define China’s approach to Southeast Asia and the broader international community.

References

  1. IMF: Debt Vulnerabilities in Belt and Road Initiative Countries
  2. Bloomberg: Mongolia-China Relations Deepen as Coal Exports Grow
  3. Reuters: Laos Faces Sovereign Default as China Takes Controlling Stake in Power Grid
  4. The Guardian: Tajikistan Gold Mine Takeover – China’s Debt and the Belt and Road
  5. IMF Board Approves $3 Billion Arrangement for Pakistan
  6. New York Times: China, Sri Lanka Port and Debt Concerns
  7. Chatham House: Belt and Road Initiative Reaches Crossroads in Central Asia
  8. IMF Statement on Debt Challenges from China Development Finance
  9. Council on Foreign Relations: China-Vietnam Relations – Tensions in the South China Sea
  10. Reuters: Malaysia’s Mahathir Cancels China-Backed Rail, Pipeline Projects
  11. U.S. Department of State: U.S. Relations with Taiwan
  12. CFR: Belt and Road Initiative – Strategic Implications and International Opposition
  13. History: Sino-Vietnamese War Ends
  14. BBC: China-India Border: Why Tensions Are Rising Between the Neighbors
  15. Brookings: China-Russia Cooperation Goes Deeper Than You Think
  16. Carnegie Endowment: China’s Belt and Road Initiative – Strategic Implications and International Opposition
  17. IMF: The BRI Turnaround
  18. Asia Society: US-Southeast Asia Relations – Heyday or Endgame?
  19. Joint Statement by the People’s Bank of China and the IMF
  20. Foreign Affairs: China’s Belt and Road Initiative Is Changing Course
  21. Financial Times: Belt and Road Debt Trap Concerns